Timing, narrative and media overhype – these three things were the main reasons for him not going in the draft. There was no dearth of talent, but the results did not match the hype created. And the biggest thing is that it is not Shedeur’s fault.
See, the truth is that the media made Shedeur a “main event” even as scouts quietly said he wasn’t first-round material. His mechanics, decision-making, and NFL-readiness were in question. But these things were buried under TV debates and viral clips.
The hype machine lifted him up, and then brought him down—on camera. Draft coverage became a kind of reality TV where one’s frustrations are met with TRPs. And Shedeur was the latest victim.
There was no lack of talent.
It’s important to remember that Shedeur isn’t a bad quarterback. He’s smart, calm under pressure, and was really impressive at the college level. But when it comes to getting ready for the NFL, decision-makers tend to play it safe. And when your last name is “Sanders,” the expectations automatically go way up.
Drafting isn’t just about skills.
It’s also about understanding that things like team fit, system, culture, and mental readiness matter just as much. Some teams were cautious because they felt Sanders’ media attention could bring unnecessary pressure into their locker room. In situations like that, they often go for a safer pick.
Is it all over now?
Not at all. This is just the beginning. Great picks still happen on Day 2 and 3. Even Brady was picked in the sixth round. Now it’s Shaduer’s chance to prove the doubters wrong — and he will.
Timeline – What happened, when?
January 2024: Sanders had a strong season for Colorado. A 9-4 record, some big wins and impressive numbers. So naturally the media started selling him as a top draft pick.
March 2024 – Pro Day and Combine Season: People expected Shedeur to perform at the combine. But he opted out, saying “I’ll try to high-proof my game with film.” Now this decision brought mixed reactions in the media.
April 2024 – Draft Week: ESPN and other channels went all hype. Graphics were made, mock drafts were showing the top 10. But real scouts and insiders were saying – “Wait, is he really ready?”
Draft Night (April 25, 2024): Pick by pick, names were announced… and Shedeur’s number did not come up. There was a live feed of his party going on, where people were just waiting to see when he would pick up the phone or respond.